Does Dodgers' TV deal shield MLB revenue?
March, 7, 2013
Mar 7
11:40
AM ET
By
Kristi Dosh | ESPN.com
When you’ve got $1 billion on the line, it’s generally smart to do your homework. That’s what the Dodgers appear to be doing, as they have yet to submit their historic $7 billion, 25-year television deal with Time Warner to Major League Baseball for approval.
The issue? How much of that deal will be subject to the league’s revenue-sharing plan.
Under the current collective bargaining agreement, the base portion of the revenue-sharing plan calls for teams to contribute 34 percent of net local revenue (which includes revenue from rights fees associated with local television contracts), minus actual expenses associated with its stadium, into a pool to be shared with other teams. That pool is divided in such a way that large-market clubs become payers into the system, with smaller-market clubs becoming recipients. However, the evolving model of teams having an ownership stake in regional sports networks has blurred the lines with regard to the portion of revenue that should be subject to revenue sharing.
When a team brokers a local television deal with a regional sports network with which it has no ownership stake, the calculation is easy: The entire rights fee is subject to revenue sharing. Under the Dodgers' current deal with Fox Sports, where the team has no ownership interest in the network, 34 percent of rights fee revenue is contributed to MLB’s revenue-sharing pool.
When a team has an ownership interest in a network, any rights fee received by the team is subject to the 34 percent local revenue sharing in the same way. However, carriage fees paid by cable providers to the regional sports network are not. For example, the Yankees own a minority share in YES Network. They receive an annual rights fee from the network, which is subject to revenue sharing. However, YES Network also receives carriage fees from cable providers. Those fees are not subject to MLB’s revenue-sharing plan.
Under the proposal as it is believed to stand currently, the Dodgers will own a new channel called SportsNetLA. Time Warner has agreed to be the channel’s charter distributor and has received the right to be the exclusive advertising and affiliate sales agent for SportsNetLA, along with managing the channel’s operations and handling distribution to other providers. All of that for the grand sum of $7 billion over 25 years.
Here’s the twist: MLB already agreed to set the fair-market value of the Dodgers rights fee at $84 million annually pursuant to a U.S. Bankruptcy Court settlement between MLB and former Dodgers owner Frank McCourt. The settlement allows for 4 percent annual increases. Those rights fees would be subject to MLB’s 34 percent local revenue-sharing plan.
The rights fees alone will generate $3.5 billion in revenue for the Dodgers. The problem is the other $3.5 billion that makes up the $7 billion deal. Sources told the New York Post that the Dodgers' revenue-sharing bill over the life of the deal could vary by up to $1 billion, depending on how much (if any) of that revenue is subject to MLB’s revenue-sharing plan.
What’s not known is exactly what that $3.5 billion represents. Forbes has reported that a “big chunk” of it will be paid to the Dodgers at the end of the 2013 season for calling the network SportsNetLA. No other MLB team has received such a payment based on the name of the RSN, and some argue it wouldn’t be any different than the fee received for stadium naming rights, which is subject to revenue sharing.
Another area of uncharted territory for MLB is the guaranteed carriage fees in the deal.
MLB allows teams who own RSNs to keep carriage fees out of the purview of revenue sharing, in part because the team is assuming the risk of owning such a network. Not only are there start-up costs, but it can takes years to sign carriage deals with the major cable and satellite providers. In the Dodgers' case, however, questions have arisen over whether the Dodgers are really assuming any kind of risk.
Time Warner is guaranteeing $4 a month from every eligible household in the Los Angeles area, regardless of whether that household receives SportsNetLA via their cable or satellite provider, and without regard to the success of the channel. In other words, if Cox doesn’t pick up SportsNetLA right away, there’s no financial loss for the Dodgers. Time Warner will cover the carriage fees of distributors who don’t sign on to carry the channel until such a time that a deal is reached with that provider.
It’s unknown whether MLB would treat this guaranteed carriage money in the same way it treats carriage fees for other team-owned RSNs, which are only generated when a channel is able to sign up and sustain carriers. It’s also unclear how much discretion MLB will have when dealing with this matter. The bankruptcy court settlement leaves authority over interpretation of the settlement’s terms, including the $84 million annual rights fee stipulated to be in the agreement, to retired federal judge Joseph Farnan.
Are the unique features of the Dodgers' deal with Time Warner, ranging from the branding fee to the guaranteed carriage fees, simply reflective of a changing marketplace, or are they an attempt to shield revenue from MLB’s revenue-sharing plan?
That’s the $1 billion question.

Under the current collective bargaining agreement, the base portion of the revenue-sharing plan calls for teams to contribute 34 percent of net local revenue (which includes revenue from rights fees associated with local television contracts), minus actual expenses associated with its stadium, into a pool to be shared with other teams. That pool is divided in such a way that large-market clubs become payers into the system, with smaller-market clubs becoming recipients. However, the evolving model of teams having an ownership stake in regional sports networks has blurred the lines with regard to the portion of revenue that should be subject to revenue sharing.
When a team brokers a local television deal with a regional sports network with which it has no ownership stake, the calculation is easy: The entire rights fee is subject to revenue sharing. Under the Dodgers' current deal with Fox Sports, where the team has no ownership interest in the network, 34 percent of rights fee revenue is contributed to MLB’s revenue-sharing pool.
When a team has an ownership interest in a network, any rights fee received by the team is subject to the 34 percent local revenue sharing in the same way. However, carriage fees paid by cable providers to the regional sports network are not. For example, the Yankees own a minority share in YES Network. They receive an annual rights fee from the network, which is subject to revenue sharing. However, YES Network also receives carriage fees from cable providers. Those fees are not subject to MLB’s revenue-sharing plan.
Under the proposal as it is believed to stand currently, the Dodgers will own a new channel called SportsNetLA. Time Warner has agreed to be the channel’s charter distributor and has received the right to be the exclusive advertising and affiliate sales agent for SportsNetLA, along with managing the channel’s operations and handling distribution to other providers. All of that for the grand sum of $7 billion over 25 years.
Here’s the twist: MLB already agreed to set the fair-market value of the Dodgers rights fee at $84 million annually pursuant to a U.S. Bankruptcy Court settlement between MLB and former Dodgers owner Frank McCourt. The settlement allows for 4 percent annual increases. Those rights fees would be subject to MLB’s 34 percent local revenue-sharing plan.
The rights fees alone will generate $3.5 billion in revenue for the Dodgers. The problem is the other $3.5 billion that makes up the $7 billion deal. Sources told the New York Post that the Dodgers' revenue-sharing bill over the life of the deal could vary by up to $1 billion, depending on how much (if any) of that revenue is subject to MLB’s revenue-sharing plan.
What’s not known is exactly what that $3.5 billion represents. Forbes has reported that a “big chunk” of it will be paid to the Dodgers at the end of the 2013 season for calling the network SportsNetLA. No other MLB team has received such a payment based on the name of the RSN, and some argue it wouldn’t be any different than the fee received for stadium naming rights, which is subject to revenue sharing.
Another area of uncharted territory for MLB is the guaranteed carriage fees in the deal.
MLB allows teams who own RSNs to keep carriage fees out of the purview of revenue sharing, in part because the team is assuming the risk of owning such a network. Not only are there start-up costs, but it can takes years to sign carriage deals with the major cable and satellite providers. In the Dodgers' case, however, questions have arisen over whether the Dodgers are really assuming any kind of risk.
Time Warner is guaranteeing $4 a month from every eligible household in the Los Angeles area, regardless of whether that household receives SportsNetLA via their cable or satellite provider, and without regard to the success of the channel. In other words, if Cox doesn’t pick up SportsNetLA right away, there’s no financial loss for the Dodgers. Time Warner will cover the carriage fees of distributors who don’t sign on to carry the channel until such a time that a deal is reached with that provider.
It’s unknown whether MLB would treat this guaranteed carriage money in the same way it treats carriage fees for other team-owned RSNs, which are only generated when a channel is able to sign up and sustain carriers. It’s also unclear how much discretion MLB will have when dealing with this matter. The bankruptcy court settlement leaves authority over interpretation of the settlement’s terms, including the $84 million annual rights fee stipulated to be in the agreement, to retired federal judge Joseph Farnan.
Are the unique features of the Dodgers' deal with Time Warner, ranging from the branding fee to the guaranteed carriage fees, simply reflective of a changing marketplace, or are they an attempt to shield revenue from MLB’s revenue-sharing plan?
That’s the $1 billion question.

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
Defendant CLC in O'Bannon case presents some evidence in its favor: http://t.co/PlFktIAwnN.
2 minutes ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Rally House, which has many Kansas locations, already pushing what looks to be Andrew Wiggins T's http://t.co/55M0hlPawj (H/T @benwoods10)
5 minutes ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Coaches won't be forced to ditch old Polaroids of plays on sidelines for Surface tablet. League anticipates by 2014 most will.
19 minutes ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Source confirms Microsoft deal with the NFL is worth $400M over 5 years.
20 minutes ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
New Microsoft deal with NFL. Teams using its Surface tablets to review plays on field, also includes sponsorship of ref replay hoods
28 minutes ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Marlins selling $32 tickets for a networking event, includes a game ticket http://t.co/jk5mYo7xMK
33 minutes ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Warriors having a fan rally tomorrow at Oracle, free parking, free entry, players too. Love that you don't have to win to throw a party
about an hour ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
One more thing about Durant: He fits his city perfectly. He has become a part of the fabric of Oklahoma City.
about an hour ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Durant is truly an outstanding guy. Absolutely nothing fake about him. Almost so real and grounded he's hard to believe.
about an hour ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Tremendous contribution by Kevin Durant to the Oklahoma tragedy, giving away what he earned in 4 3/4 games this year ($1M). True leader.
about an hour ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
I'm part of a special session at #NACDA13 for students and young admins: http://t.co/zOOJGClw0b. Limited space!
about an hour ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Think the MLS team in NY is a good deal for the Yankees. Will pay $25M to $30M of $100M expansion fee, Man City pays rest.
about 2 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
So the Sac Kings will sell out next season today? RT @AnnouncerScott One new season ticket deposit every 4 seconds.
about 2 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
New NY MLS club will immediately impact Red Bulls. Stadium in NJ has a lot of suites and club suites in it.
about 2 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
NBA does this already RT @RobBellile could they have an independent CPA firm do an audit similar to state lotteries to provide assurance?
about 2 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Legends. They are doing well RT @88PboyFWC whatever happened to the Yankees and Cowboys partnership?
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Brewers giving away nice prizes including a Bob Uecker game-worn sweater and a chance to slide down with Bernie http://t.co/T0NJjh5kAI
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
For the Cavs/LeBron lottery, the rep in the ping pong ball room brought a lucky teeth mold, since the Gunds owned Invisalign.
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Was in room for Rockets and Cavs getting #1 pick. Could not have been rigged by David Blaine.
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Team combinations come up 2X-3X in a row sometimes RT @ejmaroun Why would it take a while?
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Even offering an unedited version of the room online after the envelopes is something the NBA should look into.
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
The NBA should show the room live with the ping pong balls for the Draft Lottery. It's tedious and could take a while, but its worth it
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Yankees once did a deal with ManU. The idea was to share resources. Never worked out.
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
MLS announces MAN CITY and the Yankees have teamed up to buy the league's 20th club.
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
MLS announces ManU and the Yankees have teamed up to buy the league's 20th club. Talk about marketing power.
about 3 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
New LeBron Nike "Witness" T-shirts http://t.co/wmzjXFucVk
about 4 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
My column on why the Bobcats-to-Hornets nickname swap won't help MJ http://t.co/1pxjyjndJm
about 4 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
POLL RESULTS: 54% of fans say they care about their local stadium hosting a Super Bowl http://t.co/8aPcDxvjnk That's lower than teams think
about 4 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
POLL: How much do you care about your local stadium hosting a Super Bowl? #ALOT #INDIFFERENT #NOTATALL
about 4 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Crowne Plaza survey: 51% of PGA Tour golfers, caddies and officials say brushing teeth is not in their typical bedtime routine.
about 4 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
Charities in Minnesota launch tour to promote e-gambling to fund Vikings stadium: http://t.co/nfmbBk5w5i
about 4 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Love when sponsors commission surveys that relevantly speak to connection. Good way to break thru the clutter.
about 4 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
PGA Tour sponsor Crowne Plaza unveils survey: PGA Tour golfers, on avg, go to bed at 10:36pm and wake up at 6:48am.
about 4 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
RazorGator unveils RazorLocator, a mobile app that allows users to buy tickets with no fees. Step to attempt to steal market share
about 5 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Remember when I 1st heard the LeBron/Nike deal was approaching $90M, I thought there’s no way that was true.
about 5 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Today is the 10th anniversary of @KingJames signing his 7-year deal w/Nike. We broke it live on @OTLonESPN late in the night.
about 5 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
Paul Astleford of Visit Jacksonville says Jags playing in 4 games in London has "huge and measurable economic impact" on Jacksonville.
about 6 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Images so hard to fathom RT @Ginger_Zee #moore at sunrise http://t.co/Ext5qYhnHZ (H/T @MeredithFrost)
about 6 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
Shawn Marion has an interesting car...http://t.co/vQa0SwH8up
about 7 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
Up bright and early to go to the sports breakfast put on by @JaxBizJournal!
about 9 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Just throwing out the idea of customizing tickets. The Heat don’t do that and this was talking about the idea.
about 16 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
Love this idea of teams catering to group sales by customizing tickets http://t.co/Lcp5iKHdng (via @BrianGainor)
about 16 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- darrenrovell darren rovell
A 5-story tall Derrick Rose banner at adidas HQ had been replaced by a Damian Lillard banner (via @allanbrettman)
about 16 hours ago
- darrenrovell darren rovell

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
Excited to see so many of you who applied for my career coaching participated in #sportjc tonight. See, you don't need my help! :)
about 18 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
.@EricPalutsis It is extremely rare someone contacts me to the point of annoying me. I think it's only happened twice.
about 18 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
RT @TracieHitz: Can't help if we don't know what they need MT @SportsBizMiss: I love emails that update me on their situation. I want to he…
about 18 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
I find students are often afraid to send an email, even to someone they know. You have to get past that. Have to! #sportjc
about 18 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
RT @EricPalutsis: @SportsBizMiss in my experience, people love to help as long as you're willing to take the initiative and ask! #SportJC
about 18 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
I love when my former interns email to update me on their situation. I want to know. I want to help them. #sportjc
about 18 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh

- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh
A4: And keep in touch after your internship ends! Some of the easiest connections you'll make, so take advantage. #sportjc
about 18 hours ago
- SportsBizMiss Kristi Dosh



ESPN SPORTS BUSINESS ON TWITTER
You must be signed in to post a comment